Milburn report: what it means for young people with cystic fibrosis

Blog -

This week, Alan Milburn published his report, ‘From a Welfare State to a Working State: A new settlement for the next generation’. The report sets out a 10-year plan to reduce the number of young people not in education, employment or training, including radical changes to welfare benefits for under-25s. We are pleased to see the ambition to help more disabled young people into suitable work. But this must not come at the expense of the financial support they need to manage their health and live independently. 

In this blog, we look at what the report is proposing and what it could mean for young people with cystic fibrosis (CF). 

Changes to disability benefits 

The Milburn report proposes replacing Personal Independent Payment (PIP) and the health element of Universal Credit (UC) with a new means-tested benefit called Youth Allowance for people under the age of 25. This would be set at £338.58 a month, which is the standard rate of UC for under-25s.  

People facing additional costs because of a disability could also qualify for a new non-means-tested ‘Additional Cost Allowance’. This could provide support for things like assistance, mobility, and specialist transport. People would qualify for Additional Cost Allowance regardless of whether they are working or studying, which is important as people with CF face additional costs to stay well whatever their employment status. And for many, financial support is what makes it possible to work or study. 

We are concerned that these proposed changes could have significant financial implications for young people with CF who receive PIP. If people don’t qualify for the Additional Cost Allowance, they could be hundreds of pounds a month worse off. We urgently need the Government to clarify whether young people with CF will qualify, and how much financial support they will receive. We also need to understand how these changes will impact other benefits such as Carer’s Allowance and the Motability Scheme.

A new ‘Severe and Complex Needs Insurance’ 

A separate recommendation, called Severe and Complex Needs Insurance, is aimed at a small minority of young people who live with severe disabilities, such as those that require continuous, 24-hour care and support. This would provide a more generous and stable long-term award. However, the report doesn't explain who would qualify, how decisions would be made, or how much people would receive. These questions need answers. 

Increasing the age for Child Disability Living Allowance (DLA) 

The report also proposes increasing the age people can receive DLA from 16 to 18 years old. Moving from DLA at 16 can be challenging for people with CF. We hope this change will ensure more young people with CF receive the right support until 18. 

Overall, the potential financial impact of these proposals must not be overlooked. Living with CF costs an average of £7,753 extra each year and 38% of all people with CF under the age of 25 currently receive PIP to support these costs. Half of people with CF told us that if they no longer received PIP they would have to cut back on food, and a quarter said they would have to cut back on heating.  

Changes to employment support 

Many people with CF want to work, but finding and staying in work can be difficult due to a lack of flexible work opportunities and employers not understanding what it means to manage a long-term condition like CF.  

The report highlights the need for flexible working for young disabled people and greater employer accountability. This could create important opportunities for young people with CF. However, the report also proposes that young people who persistently refuse to engage with support could ultimately lose their Youth Allowance. 

The system must be able to distinguish between someone who is unwilling to engage and someone who is unable to do so because of their health. Young people with CF must not be punished for periods of ill health, hospitalisation or treatment that make it difficult to work, or because they have to reject work opportunities that could have negative impacts on their health. 

Will Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland be affected?  

The proposed changes to welfare will apply to people in Wales and most likely to people in Northern Ireland. People in Scotland will not be directly affected by the proposal to remove PIP because Scotland has already replaced it with Adult Disability Payment (ADP). But they would be affected by the removal of the health element of UC. For many of the other decisions proposed in the report, governments in Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland will need to decide for themselves whether to go ahead. 

What matters most to people with CF? 

The Milburn report represents a potentially important shift in disability policy, recognising that disabled people can work while still needing financial support to meet the additional costs of their condition. 

But the details about who will qualify for the Additional Cost Allowance, and how much they will receive, are critical. There is a real risk that people with fluctuating conditions like CF could be disadvantaged if the assessment is too narrow. Employment support also needs to recognise the reality of living with a lifelong and life-limiting health condition.  

What happens next? 

The Milburn report has set out recommendations, and the Government must now decide which of these proposals to take forward and how to implement them. Any changes will take time. The report is also clear that changes to benefits will not start until employment support is in place. 

The welfare system needs reform, but cutting support based on age risks pushing those with a lifelong, life-limiting condition into poor health and poverty. We will continue to advocate on behalf of people with CF to make sure that their voices are heard in these discussions.  

Any proposed changes are not imminent, but if you are worried, please contact our Helpline.  

Call 0300 373 1000 or 020 3795 2184, Monday–Friday 10am–4pm 
Email [email protected] 
Chat with us on Facebookor Instagram 
Message us on WhatsApp on 07361 582053 

decorative

Our e-newsletter

Be the first to hear about the latest CF news and research, read stories from our community, and find out how you can fundraise for Cystic Fibrosis Trust.